The Room They Called a Pantry
The house had seven rooms according to the sale particulars and eight according to the sound. Each afternoon at four, when the pipes expanded, an extra wall seemed to answer from beneath the stairs. Ines had grown up calling that space the pantry. Her father had stored preserves there. Her mother had forbidden children to touch the latch because the shelves were unsafe. Returning to prepare the house for sale, Ines repeated these facts to the agent with the pleasant certainty of a story that had never had to support weight.
The latch had been painted over. Behind it were no shelves, only a chair fixed to the floor and a small rectangular opening too high to see through while seated. Ines stood in the doorway holding the key she had found beneath a flowerpot. She remembered jars. She could see their blue lids. Yet the wall was unmarked where the shelving should have been, and the chair's front legs had worn hollows into the boards. She shut the door and spent the afternoon cleaning a kitchen that was already clean.
That night she dreamed of spooning jam into a saucer while someone knocked from the wrong side of a wall. The dream offered no trustworthy witness. She knew that much. In the morning she called her older sister and asked about the pantry. Their conversation became careful. Her sister asked whether she was alone, then said she had promised never to describe that room to Ines. Their parents were dead. The promise had survived both of them, continuing its work without supervision. Ines asked whose safety it had been meant to protect. Her sister did not say.
For days Ines moved between competing explanations. A punishment room. A sickroom. A household eccentricity enlarged by years of silence. She remembered her father's tenderness with a splinter in her hand and his sudden stillness when a glass broke. Both were memories. Neither could acquit or convict the other. She began seeing a counselor in the neighboring town, not to be handed a hidden version of her childhood but because she could no longer enter the kitchen without losing track of time. They talked about what she knew, and left room around what she did not.
Her sister finally came with a photograph. In it, their younger cousin stood beside the stair door, one wrist bandaged. He had stayed with them for a summer Ines could barely remember. Her sister told her what she had seen and what she had merely suspected. She had heard the lock turn. She had brought food. She had been fourteen. Ines wanted a single person to hate for the silence, then saw her sister watching for the expression their father used to make before deciding who was at fault. She put the photograph down between them.
They found their cousin through an aunt. He answered once and said he did not want to describe the summer. Ines apologized without asking him to supply the missing scenes. The house came off the market while she worked out what could honestly be said about it. She left the stair door open. At four, the pipes still made their ordinary noise, and sometimes her body answered before she remembered why. On the kitchen table she kept a small list of facts, ending where knowledge ended. Beside it stood an empty chair for her sister.
Continue to the lyrics